◆ Community Ranking Index

How the CRI is calculated gamescore.tromele.com

The Community Ranking Index shows how strongly a guild is publicly evidenced and discussed. It is a resonance and source score, not a measurement of DPS, raid performance or official in-game strength.

View WoW ranking Report an error
0-100 visible CRI value
3 main signals: volume, diversity, sentiment
0 invented performance data
◆ Community Ranking Index

What the CRI honestly measures

In alpha, Tromele works with publicly findable community sources. Every score should remain traceable: what counts is what is evidenced, not what would sound impressive.

What counts toward the CRI

  • How many independent sources mention a guild.
  • How many different source types appear, such as forums, Reddit, wikis or Warcraft Logs.
  • How strong the source type is. Structured or official sources weigh a little more than vague hits.
  • What sentiment is visible, but only when it is clearly present in the text.

What explicitly does not count

  • No DPS, no logs-as-performance-ranking and no raid progress as a score formula.
  • No private Discords, closed chats or login areas without clean consent.
  • No official Blizzard values and no claim that a guild is objectively the strongest in-game.
  • No invented facts: if a source is unclear, it stays neutral.
◆ CRI

The formula in plain language

The CRI combines presence with a cautious sentiment factor. More sources help, but the tenth mention does not count as strongly as the second.

CRI = presence × sentiment factor × 100

60%

Evidence volume

More independent mentions raise the value. The effect is logarithmically dampened so raw volume does not dominate everything.

20%

Source diversity

Several source types are stronger than many hits from the same corner. Around three types fills this part.

20%

Source quality

Warcraft Logs, Blizzard, Wowhead, wikis, forums, Reddit and other types have broad quality weights.

◆ AI

What the AI evaluates

AI helps classify findings: whether a result really belongs to a guild, which realm is named, what source type it is and whether the tone is clearly positive or negative. AI does not rate whether a guild plays well.

Sentiment only with coverage

If no source carries clear sentiment, the factor stays 1. The score then rests purely on evidence and diversity.

Middle path, not a blacklist

Positive tone can lift the presence value, negative tone can lower it. Visibility is not automatically a recommendation.

Sources stay visible

The ranking table shows the found sources for each guild, so the basis can be checked directly.

Why scores are normalized per game

The raw CRI is absolute. For the visible leaderboard it is scaled per game so data-poor games do not look broken: the currently strongest guild in a game lands around 95, the others proportionally below it.

Important: CRI 90 in WoW Midnight is therefore not automatically the same as CRI 90 in WoW Classic. It means: very strong within that game field.

Disputes and corrections

If an entry is wrong, outdated or assigned to the wrong guild, the guild can dispute it. Most helpful are the guild name, realm, affected link and a short explanation of what should be corrected.

Tromele does not change scores on request alone. Corrections are handled through source evidence, assignment and traceable data.

Report an error View WoW ranking